Blog home >

ST. PAUL, Minnesota, July 30, 2008 (ENS) – Conservation groups from nine states along the Mississippi River and two national groups petitioned the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency today to set and enforce numeric standards to limit nutrient pollution in the river basin because it contributes to the dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico.

The Gulf dead zone, a stretch of water covering nearly 8,000 square miles where oxygen levels are too low to support marine life, is the second largest in the world.

It is caused every year when farmers fertilize their fields. Nitrogen and phosphorus from fertilizer and phosphorus from animal manure mixes with rainwater and flows from the agricultural lands into the Mississippi River and downstream to the Gulf of Mexico.


Muddy contaminated runoff enters the
Gulf of Mexico at Plaquemines Parish,
Louisiana. (Photo courtesy USACE)

The petitioners say the EPA has disregarded its responsibility under the federal Clean Water Act to limit nutrient pollution in the Mississippi River.

“EPA’s 10 years of foot-dragging must stop,” said Kris Sigford, water quality program director for the Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy. “Our waters are sick and we’re tired of EPA’s endless stream of studies, reports, task forces and conferences while they get sicker.”

The dead zone will continue to grow, the petitioners argue, unless the EPA sets numeric standards for nitrogen and phosphorus pollution and requires all states in the river basin to meet those standards.

The petition follows Monday’s announcement of the Gulf of Mexico’s second largest dead zone to date, measuring 7,988 square miles.

Scientists from the Louisiana Universities Marine Consortium led by Nancy Rabalais, PhD., found this year’s dead zone is the second largest on record since measurements began in 1985 and is larger than the land area of Massachusetts.

Rabalais said the dead zone would have been even larger if Hurricane Dolly had not passed through the area, churning up the waters and restoring some oxygen to the zone’s edges.

“Hurricane Dolly’s winds and waves caused re-aeration of parts of the dead zone, especially along its western and shoreward edges, just before measurements were taken,” said Rabalais.

Commenting on the size of this year’s dead zone, Rob Magnien, director of NOAA’s Center for Sponsored Coastal Ocean Research, said, “Reducing nutrient pollution to protect coastal resources is one of the greatest ecosystem management challenges that we face nation-wide.”

In a report last October, the National Academy of Sciences that the EPA had shown little leadership to clean up these waters, calling the Mississippi River an “orphan.” The report concluded that, “the EPA has failed to use its mandatory and discretionary authorities under the Clean Water Act to provide adequate interstate coordination and oversight of state water quality activities along the Mississippi River.”

In 1998, the EPA called on states to adopt specific limits on nitrogen and phosphorus pollution, threatening to enact its own limits if states had not complied by 2003.

Every state along the Mississippi has ignored that and other deadlines set by the EPA, but so far, the federal agency has not acted. As a result, inland water quality problems have multiplied and the dead zone has continued to grow.

Without numeric pollution standards, the petitioners maintain, inland states along the Mississippi River have suffered severe water quality problems. Toxic algae blooms have killed fish, livestock, and pets.

Fish kills have been a frequent problem and damages to drinking water supplies have cost major metropolitan areas like St. Paul and Des Moines millions of dollars.

The petition was submitted to EPA Assistant Administrator for Water Benjamin Grumbles by – the Gulf Restoration Network Louisiana Environmental Action Network, Tennessee Clean Water Network, Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, Kentucky Waterways Alliance, Missouri Coalition for the Environment, Iowa Environmental Council, Prairie Rivers Network, Environmental Law & Policy Center, Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy, Midwest Environmental Advocates, Natural Resources Defense Council and the Sierra Club.

View This Story On Eco–mmunity Map.



WASHINGTON, DC, July 15, 2008 (ENS) – This year’s dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico is likely to be the largest on record and growing U.S. corn production is a primary cause of the worsening conditions, federal and state scientists said Tuesday.

The research team predicts that the dead zone – a stretch of water without enough oxygen to support marine life – could cover some 8,800 square miles this summer, an area roughly the size of the state of New Jersey.

The forecast was announced today by scientists with the U.S. National Oceanic Atmospheric Administration, NOAA, Louisiana Universities Marine Consortium and Louisiana State University, LSU, who predicted the dead zone would be the largest since official monitoring began in 1985.

The dead zone forms annually off the coasts of Louisiana and Texas, fed by nutrient heavy water from the Mississippi River.

The country’s largest river drains some 40 percent of the United States, including much of its agricultural heartland and its corn belt.

From as far north as Minnesota, runoff water laden with fertilizer nutrients nitrogen and phosphorous flows into river and into the Gulf, stimulating an overgrowth of algae. When the algae die, they sink to the bottom and decompose, depleting oxygen levels in the water and choking out marine life.


Fertilizers spread on an Iowa cornfield
are washed hundreds of miles
south to the Gulf of Mexico.
(Photo by Bret McVey)

“The strong link between nutrients and the dead zone indicates that excess nutrients from the Mississippi River watershed during the spring are the primary human-influenced factor behind the expansion of the dead zone,” said Rob Magnien, director of the NOAA Center for Sponsored Coastal Ocean Research.

Last year’s dead zone reached some 7,900 square miles, but the record came in 2002, when the area totalled nearly 8,500 square miles.

Record corn harvests throughout the Midwest are clearly adding to the problem, according to Eugene Turner, a scientist with LSU, and leader of the research team.

U.S. farmers are planting “an awful lot of corn and soybeans,” he told reporters, adding that both crops leach nitrogen easily into soil and groundwater.

Corn production in the United States has shot up dramatically in recent years, driven by demand for corn-based ethanol. The U.S. Agriculture Department estimates some 87 million acres of corn were planted this year.

“The nitrogen is undoubtedly coming down in larger amounts because there’s more planting of corn this year than there has been in a very long time,” Turner said.

Some 817,000 tons of nitrogen, roughly 35-45 percent above normal, seeped into the Gulf between April and June, according to the U.S. Geological Survey, USGS.

Added to the mix is a record amount of phosphorous flowing into the Gulf.

The USGS reported that 85,000 tons of phosphorous entered the Gulf from April through June, some 85 percent above normal levels.

Turner said his team is uncertain what impact last month’s record floods in the Midwest will have on the dead zone.

Although researchers can’t quantify the effects yet, he added, it is likely that the zone will expand from as a large pulse of floodwater coming down the Mississippi enters the Gulf.


Mississippi River plume meets Gulf of
Mexico water at Southwest Pass,
a primary shipping channel in
Louisiana waters. (Photo by N.
Rabelais courtesy USGS)

“We just don’t quite know yet what the full effect will be,” Turner said.

Crews are heading out into the Gulf on Sunday to begin this year’s official dead zone measuring.

“We expect a final [figure] to be available about a week or two from now,” Magnien told reporters on a press telebriefing.

Turner warned that the economic impact of the dead zone would again ripple through the Gulf’s lucrative commercial and recreational fishing industries.

“The fish and shrimp have left this area and it is inconceivable that you could have that much change on the bottom and not change the fisheries in some way,” Turner said. “This area is about 25-30 percent of U.S. fisheries – it is a pretty big fishery that is under threat.”

Changing conditions to prevent the annual dead zone won’t be easy, he added. “It is not just a matter of turning the switch today.”

“It is going to have to come from changes in land use,” Turner said. “We will have to reduce the amount of nitrogen coming off the watershed.”

He suggested farmers move away from perennial crops that leave the land barren and susceptible to flooding, but warned that reductions in nutrient runoff will not yield instant results. Nitrogen is stored in the soil and can continue leaching for many years.

The report comes as some 250 corn growers from more than 20 states are convening in Washington, DC this week for the biannual Corn Congress meeting of the National Corn Growers Association.

Ron Litterer, NCGA president and a grower from Iowa, said, “We especially find it important to set aside time for farmers to meet with their representatives and senators and tell them what’s important for growers back home.”

In February, NCGA corn growers, conservation organizations and companies throughout the agriculture supply chain teamed up to launch a first-of-its-kind working group to help establish sustainable outcomes for agriculture.

The group’s initial focus will be creating a sustainability index to analyze and report use of land, water, energy, greenhouse gas emissions and crop production inputs in four key commodity crops � corn, cotton, soybeans and wheat.

For World Wildlife Fund, Jason Clay said at the launch, “Continued improvements in efficient land use will be critical if we’re going to meet the ever-growing demand for food and fiber without putting more pressure on our environmental resources.”

By J.R. Pegg

View This Story On Eco–mmunity Map.