A good juxtaposition of New Orleans shambles to the isolated life of college. Flash images of rumble, then SUV windshield view as one flies past the locals. We ask ourselves do these kids really "get it"? A little background on each hints that perhaps they can relate to the plight.
The candid eavesdropping of student-to-student talk says it all: "How do I get my message across?" [This is just like my former architectural studio days of the 70's.]
The film's eye captures the fleeting snapshots of the neighborhood, just as they are used in the design: They are snapped, never discussed, and suddenly discarded. We see the student's limited client involvement as a quick bar-b-que. No sense of:" let's talk a walk in your shoes", sit down and go over what is very important to you in a home's design in this neighborhood, in this city, and on this street.
I like the way each designer is given a little film time. Not overdone. Just a few clicks to get a sense of what makes him/her care about this assignment.
The upcoming construction scenes will probably give a little more insight into how much each will learn and gleam from this opportunity. Each will take away a slightly different take on how this effort will do any benefit at all or just a labor of sweat. Do any of them really learn anything; does the NHS get a good viable house?
|